Blood pressure control lost stars as scores rose
The median score rose from 79% to 81%, and CMS moved the 4-star cut point from 80% to 84%. 202 contracts lost stars on this measure and 44 gained.
How Clara helps with chronic careCMS data · Updated Nov 12, 2026
We compared the CMS 2027 and 2026 Star Ratings for all 735 Medicare Advantage and Part D contracts. Search for a plan to see which measures moved and how it compares with similar plans.
183 of 468
Contracts got a lower overall rating in 2027
88 rose and 197 held
72
Contracts fell from 4+ stars to under 4
35 moved up past 4 stars
188
Contracts at 4 stars or more for 2027
Down from 229 in 2026 (37% of rated contracts)
14 of 22
2026 five-star contracts lost 5 stars
CMS lists 15 five-star MA-PD contracts for 2027
Overall ratings for MA-PD contracts rated in both years. Source: CMS Star Ratings data tables, 2027 and 2026.
Measures with higher cut points
CMS raised the score needed for 4 stars on several measures that depend on reaching members. Many plans scored higher on these measures in 2027 and still lost a star.
The median score rose from 79% to 81%, and CMS moved the 4-star cut point from 80% to 84%. 202 contracts lost stars on this measure and 44 gained.
How Clara helps with chronic care242 contracts lost stars and 93 gained. The average fell from 3.07 to 2.74 stars, while the median score rose from 87% to 89%. The MA-PD 4-star cut point rose from 89% to 91%.
How Clara helps with adherenceFollow-up after an ED visit for people with multiple chronic conditions averaged 2.54 stars in 2027, down from 2.83. 190 contracts lost stars and 34 gained. The 4-star cut point rose from 67% to 72%.
How Clara helps after ED visitsOn Plan All-Cause Readmissions, 213 contracts gained stars and 45 lost them. On Transitions of Care, 158 gained and 36 lost, and the median score rose from 62% to 67%.
How Clara helps after dischargeThe median score for kidney health checks in members with diabetes rose from 61% to 68%, while CMS moved the 4-star cut point from 62% to 72%. 175 contracts lost stars and 24 gained.
How Clara helps close HEDIS gapsAmong 341 rated contracts with Special Needs Plans, the bottom quarter completed assessments for 66% of members or fewer. The top quarter reached 90% or more.
How Clara completes HRAsWhy stars fell
We rebuilt each 2026 and 2027 measure star from the CMS cut points, and our rebuild matches the CMS star about 99% of the time. For each lost star we could rebuild, we checked whether the plan's score fell, the cut point rose, or both. Member survey (CAHPS) measures are left out, because CMS doesn't set their stars with simple cut points.
45%
of star losses came from the score falling
The 2027 score would have lost the star even under the 2026 cut point. Out of 3,161 traced losses.
33%
came from the cut point rising
CMS raised the cut point above the plan's 2026 score
22%
needed both
Both the lower score and the higher cut point played a part
400
times a plan raised its score and still lost the star
On these measures, CMS raised the cut point and that caused more than half of the lost stars.
Score needed for 4 stars: 89% in 2026, 91% in 2027
153 from a higher bar, 63 from both, 12 from a lower score.
Score needed for 4 stars: 80% in 2026, 84% in 2027
122 from a higher bar, 78 from both, 1 from a lower score.
Score needed for 4 stars: 62% in 2026, 72% in 2027
167 from a higher bar, 8 from both, 0 from a lower score.
Score needed for 4 stars: 89% in 2026, 90% in 2027
92 from a higher bar, 55 from both, 24 from a lower score.
Score needed for 4 stars: 67% in 2026, 72% in 2027
105 from a higher bar, 46 from both, 4 from a lower score.
On these measures, the cut point held or dropped, and lower scores caused more than half of the lost stars.
Score needed for 4 stars: 80% in 2026, 79% in 2027
0 from a higher bar, 4 from both, 153 from a lower score.
Score needed for 4 stars: 90% in 2026, 90% in 2027
0 from a higher bar, 1 from both, 107 from a lower score.
Score needed for 4 stars: 0.32 or less in 2026, 0.33 or less in 2027
0 from a higher bar, 3 from both, 86 from a lower score.
Score needed for 4 stars: 17% or less in 2026, 17% or less in 2027
0 from a higher bar, 4 from both, 72 from a lower score.
Score needed for 4 stars: 97% in 2026, 97% in 2027
0 from a higher bar, 3 from both, 72 from a lower score.
Score needed for 4 stars: 91% in 2026, 90% in 2027
0 from a higher bar, 0 from both, 74 from a lower score.
Score needed for 4 stars: 53% in 2026, 52% in 2027
0 from a higher bar, 7 from both, 43 from a lower score.
Score needed for 4 stars: 69% in 2026, 69% in 2027
0 from a higher bar, 1 from both, 35 from a lower score.
Score needed for 4 stars: 9% or less in 2026, 10% or less in 2027
0 from a higher bar, 0 from both, 35 from a lower score.
Outreach measures with 20 or more traced star losses. We count only stars we could rebuild from the CMS cut points in both years, so these counts can be lower than the counts in the measure table. Colorectal Cancer Screening is left out because CMS redefined it for 2027.
183 MA-PD contracts lost overall stars. Only 19 of them lost most of their weighted stars to higher cut points.
Where the losses came from
We weighted each lost star by the measure's weight and the plan's members. In the CAHPS and HOS surveys, members rate their care, their plan and their own health.
Share of all member-weighted star losses. The number in brackets is the measure's weight in the overall rating.
Parent companies and states
We weight each contract by its members, using CMS November 2026 enrollment. The last column shows the share of members in plans with 4 stars or more, the level CMS uses for quality bonus payments.
120 of 286 contracts with Special Needs Plans lost overall stars, against 63 of 182 without. Their member-weighted average fell from 4.04 to 3.95.
Contracts with 10,000 to 50,000 members fell from 3.80 to 3.59 on a member-weighted basis. 74 of 183 lost stars and 25 gained.
| Parent company | Members | Average stars | Contracts lost / gained | Members in 4+ star plans |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| UnitedHealth Group, Inc.50 contracts | 9,162,468 | 4.133.93 | 25 / 6 | 8368 % |
| Humana Inc.30 contracts | 7,067,512 | 3.844.18 | 3 / 19 | 4295 % |
| CVS Health Corporation38 contracts | 4,132,134 | 4.223.99 | 16 / 5 | 8570 % |
| Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc.9 contracts | 2,077,550 | 4.424.48 | 1 / 3 | 100100 % |
| Elevance Health, Inc.34 contracts | 1,762,636 | 3.913.83 | 12 / 5 | 5748 % |
| Health Care Service Corporation21 contracts | 876,710 | 3.903.39 | 11 / 2 | 5413 % |
| Centene Corporation42 contracts | 758,799 | 3.413.27 | 15 / 3 | 1910 % |
| Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan Mutual Ins. Co.3 contracts | 622,754 | 4.494.49 | 0 / 0 | 9999 % |
| SCAN Group4 contracts | 457,605 | 4.013.98 | 2 / 0 | 10096 % |
| Highmark Health7 contracts | 419,911 | 4.384.32 | 2 / 0 | 9686 % |
| Healthfirst, Inc.4 contracts | 377,227 | 4.463.48 | 3 / 0 | 960 % |
| Devoted Health, Inc.22 contracts | 361,520 | 4.264.05 | 9 / 5 | 7374 % |
| Aware Integrated, Inc.3 contracts | 345,289 | 4.343.91 | 2 / 0 | 8682 % |
| Lifetime Healthcare, Inc.4 contracts | 333,192 | 3.983.76 | 2 / 0 | 7453 % |
| Alignment Healthcare USA, LLC6 contracts | 297,910 | 4.163.71 | 3 / 1 | 10024 % |
| Corewell Health3 contracts | 287,113 | 4.274.27 | 0 / 0 | 9797 % |
| Guidewell Mutual Holding Corporation5 contracts | 262,381 | 4.154.20 | 2 / 2 | 7459 % |
| Medica Holding Company4 contracts | 257,911 | 3.473.55 | 1 / 3 | 055 % |
| UPMC Health System4 contracts | 226,385 | 4.414.32 | 2 / 0 | 9983 % |
| CuraCor Solutions Corp.3 contracts | 183,418 | 4.094.08 | 1 / 0 | 9898 % |
| Independence Health Group, Inc.4 contracts | 144,042 | 3.923.87 | 1 / 1 | 9578 % |
| California Physicians' Service4 contracts | 124,048 | 3.723.40 | 1 / 1 | 4456 % |
| Risant Health, Inc.4 contracts | 118,985 | 4.503.93 | 3 / 0 | 10084 % |
| Point32Health, Inc.3 contracts | 118,034 | 3.933.92 | 1 / 0 | 8685 % |
| Molina Healthcare, Inc.10 contracts | 111,906 | 3.183.22 | 2 / 2 | 99 % |
Largest 25 parent companies with 3 or more rated contracts. States with 20,000 or more visible MA-PD members. CMS hides county counts of 10 or fewer, and both years use November 2026 enrollment. Contract counts include plans whose enrollment CMS hides because they have 10 or fewer members.
Who moved
Pick a measure and a state to list each plan that lost or gained stars on it, largest plans first.
Loading plans…
All outreach measures
Medical records and pharmacy claims record the care members got, and member surveys record how members rated it. Weight shows how much each measure counts toward the overall rating.
| Measure | Weight | Average stars | Lost stars | Gained stars | 2027 median score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Breast Cancer ScreeningMedical records | 1x | 3.243.28 | 60 | 72 | 75 |
| Colorectal Cancer Screening(changed for 2027)Medical records | 1x | 3.45 | — | — | 75 |
| Annual Flu VaccineMember survey | 1x | 3.223.09 | 109 | 83 | 65 |
| Diabetes Care - Eye ExamMedical records | 1x | 3.403.16 | 164 | 44 | 77 |
| Kidney Health Evaluation for Patients with DiabetesMedical records | 1x | 3.463.18 | 175 | 24 | 68 |
| Osteoporosis Management in Women who had a FractureMedical records | 1x | 2.752.80 | 51 | 77 | 45 |
| Care for Older Adults - Medication ReviewMedical records | 1x | 4.164.18 | 58 | 53 | 99 |
| Care for Older Adults - Functional Status AssessmentMedical records | 1x | 3.99 | — | — | 94 |
| Special Needs Plan (SNP) Care ManagementPlan operations | 1x | 3.533.46 | 93 | 32 | 79 |
| Measure | Weight | Average stars | Lost stars | Gained stars | 2027 median score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Transitions of CareMedical records | 1x | 3.113.40 | 36 | 158 | 67 |
| Follow-up after Emergency Department Visit for People with Multiple High-Risk Chronic ConditionsMedical records | 1x | 2.832.54 | 190 | 34 | 62 |
| Plan All-Cause ReadmissionsMedical records | 3x | 2.953.41 | 45 | 213 | 10 |
| Medication Reconciliation Post-Discharge(2026 only)Medical records | — | — | — | — | — |
| Measure | Weight | Average stars | Lost stars | Gained stars | 2027 median score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Controlling High Blood PressureMedical records | 3x | 3.403.03 | 202 | 44 | 81 |
| Diabetes Care - Blood Sugar ControlledMedical records | 3x | 3.603.71 | 80 | 121 | 89 |
| Statin Therapy for Patients with Cardiovascular DiseaseMedical records | 1x | 3.263.25 | 102 | 101 | 88 |
| Statin Use in Persons with Diabetes (SUPD)Pharmacy claims | 1x | 3.293.11 | 171 | 46 | 88 |
| Measure | Weight | Average stars | Lost stars | Gained stars | 2027 median score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Medication Adherence for Diabetes MedicationsPharmacy claims | 3x | 3.072.74 | 242 | 93 | 89 |
| Medication Adherence for Hypertension (RAS antagonists)Pharmacy claims | 3x | 3.223.40 | 79 | 159 | 90 |
| Medication Adherence for Cholesterol (Statins)Pharmacy claims | 3x | 3.213.23 | 121 | 108 | 89 |
| MTM Program Completion Rate for CMR(2026 only)Plan operations | — | — | — | — | — |
| Measure | Weight | Average stars | Lost stars | Gained stars | 2027 median score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Getting Needed CareMember survey | 2x | 3.393.35 | 121 | 103 | 82 |
| Getting Appointments and Care QuicklyMember survey | 2x | 3.553.74 | 77 | 92 | 84 |
| Customer ServiceMember survey | 2x | 3.473.36 | 112 | 84 | 90 |
| Care CoordinationMember survey | 2x | 3.503.55 | 84 | 89 | 88 |
| Rating of Health PlanMember survey | 2x | 3.423.37 | 130 | 97 | 87 |
| Members Choosing to Leave the PlanPlan operations | 2x | 3.733.69 | 76 | 87 | 14 |
| Complaints about the Health PlanPlan operations | 2x | 4.113.97 | 93 | 70 | 0.2 |
| Call Center - Foreign Language Interpreter and TTY AvailabilityPlan operations | 2x | 4.164.39 | 75 | 191 | 100 |
Look up a plan
Open a contract to see each measure's stars in 2026 and 2027, and where its 2027 score sits among its peers.
735 contracts
Outreach and Star Ratings
Screenings, follow-up after a hospital or ED visit, refills and health risk assessments all need a call that gets answered. Clara, the AI care agent from Pythagoras AI, calls and texts members in 35+ languages. She books visits and screenings and hands health questions to your nurses by warm handoff. We manage Clara. Your team stays in charge.
Method
Questions
468 MA-PD contracts had an overall rating in both 2026 and 2027. Of those, 183 got a lower rating in 2027, 88 got a higher one and 197 stayed the same. 33 dropped a full star or more.
72 contracts went from 4 stars or more in 2026 to under 4 stars in 2027. 35 moved the other way. 188 contracts have 4 stars or more for 2027, down from 229. Four stars is the level CMS uses for quality bonus payments.
CMS sets new cut points every year. For 2027 the cut points went up on several measures. On Controlling High Blood Pressure the median score rose from 79% to 81%, but the 4-star cut point rose from 80% to 84%. 202 contracts lost stars on that measure and 44 gained.
Screening, blood pressure and Transitions of Care measures come from HEDIS medical records. Medication adherence comes from pharmacy claims. Getting needed care, getting appointments quickly, customer service and plan ratings come from the CAHPS member survey, so they show how members felt. Complaints, members leaving the plan and call center checks come from plan operations data. This page labels each measure.
Medication Adherence for Diabetes Medications lost the most: 242 contracts lost stars and 93 gained. Follow-up after an ED visit for people with multiple chronic conditions has the lowest average, 2.54 stars. Plan All-Cause Readmissions and Transitions of Care gained the most: 213 and 158 contracts gained stars.
From the CMS Star Ratings data tables for 2027 (released October 8, 2026) and 2026 (the version CMS recalculated on July 22, 2026), and the CMS monthly enrollment files. We matched measures by name because CMS measure IDs change. A blank means CMS did not publish a rating, for example because the plan is too new or too small.
Most of these measures depend on reaching members on time: booking screenings, calling soon after a hospital or ED visit, and checking in on refills. Clara, the AI care agent from Pythagoras AI, calls and texts members, books visits and screenings, and hands health questions to your nurses by warm handoff. We manage Clara. Your team stays in charge.
Get Started
Book a 30-minute demo. We will discuss your team's needs and show how you could get the results.